File No. 861.00/1851

The Ambassador in Great Britain ( Page ) to the Secretary of State

No. 9011

Sir: At the request of Professor Antoine Piip, who is described on his visiting card as diplomatic representative of Esthonia and member of the Esthonian Council, and who is at present residing in London, I have the honor to transmit herewith, for such attention as the Department may see fit to give, copies of certain documents on the political situation in Esthonia.

Mr. Piip called to see me at the Embassy yesterday but I did not receive him, directing the Counselor of the Embassy to see him in my stead, and he then left these papers with the request that they be transmitted to you.

I have [etc.]

Walter Hines Page
[Page 827]
[Enclosure 1]

The Esthonian Delegation to the American Ambassador in Great Britain ( Page )

Sir: In January last and February the representatives of the Esthonian people have visited the Ambassador of the United States of America in Petrograd, and expressed the national desire of Esthonia for independence, pronounced by the democratic Esthonian Diet, or National Council, and confirmed in January by the authorized United Assembly of the Presidency of Council, the Committee of Ancients and Country Government. It was declared that Esthonia should be also a perpetual neutral state, and a free country for international trade.

At the same time, the whole of the Esthonian people protested against the occupation of the country by Germans.

In consequence of recent events in Esthonia, the most important of which is the invasion of the country by German troops, we, being authorized, have the honor to make this declaration and to beg you to transmit it to your Government, the answer to be transmitted to the plenipotentiary representative of the Esthonian provisional government in London, Professor Antonius Piip.

Contrary to the will of the Esthonian people and its representative organs, the Esthonian German nobility decided on the 28th of January 1918 to make an appeal to the German Government to occupy the country with German troops. Against such an appeal the authorized representative of the provisional government of Esthonia in Stockholm has made, on the 4th of February 1918, a protest to the German Government.

However, after the resumption of hostilities on the part of Germany against Russia, the German troops have crossed the Moon Sound and occupied Verder, Leal, etc. The German motive in occupying the country was to combat the anarchy of the free-handed actions of the Bolsheviks, who declared all the Esthonian nobility to be outlaws.

Nevertheless, the Esthonian provisional government had succeeded in overthrowing the domination of the Bolsheviks, and in establishing legal order with the help of loyal Esthonian troops before the German invasion.

On the 24th of February, the last representatives of the Bolshevik government left the country, going on Russian warships to Helsingfors. Immediately afterwards the new government of the independent democratic republic of Esthonia was finally formed in the following manner:

Prime Minister, Minister of Internal Affairs and Trade, member of the Esthonian Diet, Konstantin Pats; his assistant; Minister of Justice, member of the Diet, Jüri Wilms; Minister of Foreign Affairs, member of the Russian Constituent Assembly from Esthonia, Jaan Poska; War Minister, Commander in Chief of Esthonian troops, Colonel of General Staff, M. Laidoner; Minister of Finance and Domains of the State, member of the Diet, Johan Kukk; Minister of Agriculture, member of the Diet, Jaan Raamot; Minister of Ways and Communications, Ferdinand Petersen; Minister of Labor and Charitable Board, member of the Diet, Willem Maasik; Minister of Education, member of the Diet, Peter Pold.

The authorized Provisional Government of Esthonia has reestablished the order in the country. All the confiscations and requisitions made by the Bolsheviks have been declared null and void. All the property has been returned to its former proprietors.

The Germans, however, continued their advance, and soon afterwards occupied the whole country.

[Page 828]

According to information to hand, the situation in Esthonia at present is as follows:

The government is deprived of its power de facto; the Esthonian troops are disarmed; the town democratic self-governments, elected and established in 1917, are dismissed; in Revel a German was appointed mayor of the town; with him a committee composed of eighteen Germans was also appointed; Esthonians refused to participate in this committee; in Dorpat a German merchant was also appointed the mayor of the town; in the villages, all the district committees established on the basis of the common electoral laws are dismissed and, in their place, self-governing censuses of 1914 were appointed.

Under such conditions, the formation of an Esthonian Constituent Assembly is practically impossible, and more so since the process of elections could not be completed before the German invasion. The formation of a Constituent Assembly can only be possible and expedient when the German troops have completely left the country.

It is necessary, however, to note that the elections to the Esthonian Constituent Assembly were de facto at the same time a referendum on the independence of Esthonia. Seventy per cent voted for the absolute independence of Esthonia, the rest for autonomy, but as a part of the Russian federation. Thus it is evident that the democratic will expressed by the people goes to show that independence is needed for Esthonia. At the present time, while the German troops are in the country, the only recognized and lawful government of Esthonia is the Esthonian Diet, and the provisional government authorized by this Diet of which we are the representatives.

We know that German nobility Landtags of Estland and Livland will speak on behalf of the country, expressing their desire for a personal union with Prussia, but they have no right whatever to make such a declaration. A detailed protest against such an unlawful attempt by this nobility, was made to the German Government by the Esthonian delegation in Stockholm on the 21st of March 1918. A new protest against the resolution of the Liv-Esthonian Landesrat’s proposition of a union with Prussia was made to the German Chancellor and Foreign Secretary of State by the plenipotentiary Esthonian delegation in Christiania on the 13th of April 1918.

We may also add that Russia was asked to immediately declare her recognition of Esthonia’s independence on supposition that the general democratic parliament decided over Esthonia’s future political state and international position but not the Liv-Esthonian German nobility or appointed Landesrat; this supposition we maintain in like manner.

In consideration of all the above said, we have the honor to ask the Government of United States of America—

(1)
To recognize the independence of the democratic republic of Esthonia within her ethnographical frontiers, including the isles of the Moon Sound;
(2)
To recognize the provisional government authorized by the Esthonian Diet as the only legal power of Esthonia; and
(3)
To grant to Esthonia the right to participate at the general peace conference, so as to be able to defend her interests and introduce the question of Esthonian perpetual neutrality and its international guarantees.

We have [etc.]

  • Ant. Piip
  • K. R. Pusta
  • Edward Wirgo
    Authorized Representatives of Esthonia

[Page 829]
[Enclosure 2]

The British Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs ( Balfour ) to the Esthonian Representatives 1

71866/W/38

Gentlemen: I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your letter enclosing a memorandum on the political situation of Esthonia, and asking for recognition from His Majesty’s Government.

It gave me much pleasure to receive your recent visit, and I take this opportunity of assuring you that His Majesty’s Government greet with sympathy the aspirations of the Esthonian people and are glad to reaffirm their readiness to grant provisional recognition to the Esthonian National Council as a de facto independent body, until the peace conference takes place, when the future status of Esthonia ought to be settled as far as possible in accordance with the wishes of the population. It would obviously be impossible for His Majesty’s Government at the present time to guarantee to Esthonia the right to participate at the peace conference, but at any such conference His Majesty’s Government will do their utmost to secure that the above principle is applied to Esthonia.

In the meantime His Majesty’s Government will be glad to receive Professor Antonius Piip as the informal diplomatic representative of the Esthonian provisional government.

I have [etc.]

Arthur James Balfour
  1. Copies of letters in similar terms from the French Minister of Foreign Affairs, under date of May 13, and the Italian Minister of Foreign Affairs, under date of May 29, were given by one of the Esthonian delegates to the Chargé in Denmark and forwarded by him as enclosures to his despatch No, 1754, Sept. 13, 1918 (File No. 861.00/3031).