No. 217.

Mr. Bayard to Mr. Becerra.

Sir: I have the honor to inclose a copy of a letter from the Attorney-General, calling attention to discrepancies in the statements received by the United States attorney, southern district of New York, in the matter of the brig Ambrose Light.

Accept, &c.,

T. F. BAYARD.
[Inclosure.]

Mr. Garland to Mr. Bayard.

Sir: I have the honor to send you for your information a copy of a letter of the 18th instant from Mr. Root, by his assistant, attorney of the United States for the [Page 278] southern district of New York, calling attention to discrepancies in the official information given the attorney by the Colombian minister at Washington and the Colombian consul at New York.

Very respectfully,

A. H. GARLAND,
Attorney-General.
[Inclosure in inclosure.]

Mr. Clarice to Mr. Garland.

Sir: I have the honor to call your attention to a discrepancy in the official information given the district attorney by the Colombian minister at Washington and by the Colombian consul here in regard to the brig Ambrose Light, captured by the United States ship Alliance.

Your letter of 2d instant inclosed a copy of the note of the Colombian minister to the Secretary of State, dated May 27, 1885, wherein the minister states: “I have information whose authenticity and reliable source authorizes me to state to the Government of the honorable Secretary of State that the brig Ambrose Light, which was captured on the 17th instant by the American war vessel Alliance on the Caribbean Sea, under circumstances which gave reasons to suspect her, was purchased at Philadelphia for the Colombian rebels by their agent, Benjamin Gaitan, who dispatched her with some munitions of war to the scene of the rebellion, where she was assigned to the transportation of troops. This aforesaid agent, the purchaser of the vessel, has just given this information to the consul of Colombia at New York, &c.”

Upon the receipt of your letter the district attorney wrote the Colombian consul, giving him the substance of the minister’s statement, and asking him to call at this office with his witnesses, to the end that it might be ascertained whether there had been a breach of our neutrality laws.

I have now at hand the reply of the consul to the district attorney’s letter, in which he states: “I deem it convenient to advise you that I have said nothing in reference to Mr. Gaitan purchasing the Ambrose Light, neither his having dispatched her with munitions of war to the Colombian rebels. He merely informed me that the brig had been purchased at Barranquilla by the revolutionists.”

Very respectfully,

SAM’L B. CLARKE,
Assistant United States Attorney.